FIELD NOTES / MATERIALS
I have a hard time with the word sustainable.
A boulder is natural, but somebody took it out of the ground and put it on a truck. Steel takes a lot of energy to make, but a steel wall may still be there long after I’m gone. Brick is made from clay and lasts almost forever, but it has to be fired.
So I don’t think there’s a clean list of sustainable materials.

WEATHERED BOULDERS
USE WHAT’S ALREADY THERE
This one is easier.
If there’s a pile of old brick beside the house, use it. If there are old stones on the property, find somewhere for them to go.
Make a path. Build a fire pit. Put them into a wall.
Every material already on the site that we can use is something we don’t have to manufacture, buy, haul in or haul away.

OLD BRICK + STONE
LONGEVITY COUNTS
I like brick. It feels permanent because it usually is.
The same is true of steel. It takes energy to produce, but a thin steel retaining wall can last a very long time, takes up very little space and can do its job without the footprint of a large block wall.
Does steel leach something into the soil over time? I don’t know. It’s worth asking.
That’s part of the problem with calling something sustainable. There is almost always another question.

STEEL

BRICK / STUCCO
WHAT LEAVES THE SITE MATTERS TOO
We tear out concrete.
If that concrete can go to a recycler rather than a landfill, that matters. If removing an old concrete surface lets us replace it with planting or a permeable surface, that matters too.
Construction has an impact. I think the better question is what we do with that impact.
NATURAL DOESN’T ALWAYS MEAN SUSTAINABLE
A dry creek bed made from river rock may be one of my least favorite additions to a local landscape.
It looks natural. But the stone came from somewhere.
The same question applies to pea gravel and other aggregates. Quarrying, dredging, processing and transportation are still part of the material even when we don’t see them once the garden is finished.
Sometimes plants can do the job better anyway.
Instead of a two-foot-wide strip of river rock running a hundred feet through a property, why not plant a two-foot-wide strip of Acorus?
It can describe the same movement through the landscape, except it’s alive.
THERE ISN’T A PERFECT MATERIAL
I use stone, brick, concrete, steel, gravel and wood. None of them gets a sustainability halo just because of what it’s made from.
I think about where it came from, how much of it we need, what was there before it, how long the new thing should last, what we’re removing, and whether something already on the property could do the job.
Sometimes the most sustainable material is simply the one that’s already there.
← RETURN TO FIELD NOTES